HWffakSYW Wf W`fdWf[W`
FS egdXSUW ^S fST^W VW Ug[eea` bWgf pfdW `WffakoW Ua__W [`V[cgo U[0VWeeage=
H[hWSg VW
eS^[eegdW
f[k iWb[
jhvi iWb[
hwi_Zki
ikYh[ \edZk Wl[Y
Zk fbWij_gk[ ek
Z[ b-Wbkc_d_kc
KW_SdcgW= VoTdS`UZWd ^,SbbSdW[^ o^WUfda_o`SYWd ShS`f VW ^W `WffakWd1
L[Y`S^[eSf[a` VW bS``We Wf ea^gf[a`e
Q_ kd[ WdecWb_[ i[ fheZk_j1 bW jWXb[ _dZkYj_ed ZwYb[dY^[ WkjecWj_gk[c[dj kd ceZ[ fhej[Yj_ed
[j b[i YeZ[i ik_lWdji WffWhW_ii[dj ikh b-W\\_Y^[kh?
JdaT^n_W
F54F64F7
C[Y_ [ij kd[ b_ij[ Z[i fWdd[i b[i fbki YekhWdj[i3
M[ fWi Zwcedj[h bW jWXb[ Z[ Yk_iied wb[Yjh_gk[ i[kb W\_d Z-wl_j[h jekj h_igk[ ek
cxc[ Z[ fhelegk[h Z[i Zw]tji fbki _cfehjWdji3
LWdh[UW >bdne0OW`fW
Q_ b-WffWh[_b wb[YjhecwdW][h d[ \edYj_edd[ fWi X_[d1 WlWdj Z[ YedjWYj[h b[ i[hl_Y[ Wfhvi2l[dj[1
deki leki Yedi[_bbedi Z[?
2
lwh_\_[h gk[ bW \_Y^[ [ij Yehh[Yj[c[dj _diwhw[ ZWdi bW fh_i[ wb[Yjh_gk[3
2
K_h[ b[ jWXb[Wk Z[ i_]dWb_iWj_ed Z[i fWdd[i fW][ 663
Q_1 Wfhvi Y[i lwh_\_YWj_edi1 b[ fheXbvc[ f[hi_ij[1 wj[_dZh[ b-WffWh[_b1 d[ fWi b[ Zwcedj[h [j Wff[b[h
b[ Q[hl_Y[ Afhvi2T[dj[3
@a__W`f `WffakWd
Wl[Y Z[ b-[Wk Y^WkZ[@ fk_i [iiko[h
Wl[Y Z[ b-[Wk Y^WkZ[ [j bWl[h Wl[Y
kd[ wfed][ WXhWi_l[ ifwY_Wb[ fekh
h[lxj[c[dj l_jheYwhWc_gk[
l[hi[h Zk l_dW_]h[ XbWdY ikh b[i
hwi_Zki [j d[jjeo[h Wl[Y kd b_d][
Zekn
Oekh [db[l[h b[i hwi_Zki1 kj_b_i[h kd
hWYbe_h fekh h[lxj[c[dj l_jheYwhWc_gk[
.fekh fhejw][h b[ l[hh[1 _b [ij fhw\whWXb[
Z-kj_b_i[h kd fheZk_j s XWi[ Z[ i_b_Yed[/3
K[ ikYh[ i[ h[j_h[ W Y^WkZ3 Ajj[dj_ed Z[
d[ fWi leki Xh{b[h3
@SgeWe bdaTST^We
l[dj_bWj[kh [dZeccW]w
YWfj[kh Z[ j[cfwhWjkh[
F82F=
[dZeccW]w
j[di_ed wb[Yjh_gk[
E64E7
WdehcWb[
j[cfwhWjkh[
E84E9
WdehcWb[
hWoedd[c[dj Z[ bW
E:4E;
Y^Wb[kh _dik\\_iWdj
>UUWeea[dW m gf[^[eWd
bagd ^W `WffakSYW
wfed][ ifwY_Wb[ fekh
h[lxj[c[dj l_jheYwhWc_gk[
OheZk_ji ifwY_Wkn fekh
h[lxj[c[dj l_jheYwhWc_gk[
OheZk_ji ifwY_Wkn fekh
h[lxj[c[dj l_jheYwhWc_gk[
La^gf[a`
YedjWYj[h b[ \ekhd_ii[kh
YedjWYj[h b[ \ekhd_ii[kh
lwh_\_[h gk[ b-WffWh[_b [ij
ieki j[di_ed3 Afhvi Y[jj[
lwh_\_YWj_ed1 Wbbkc[h1 s
dekl[Wk1 b-WffWh[_b
lwh_\_[h bW YWii[heb[
Wfhvi ied
h[\he_Z_ii[c[dj1 Wbbkc[h
s dekl[Wk b-WffWh[_b
27
wfed][